The Number Isn't the Problem
Stop tweaking your pricing and start fixing what happens before the number ever appears.
Book Review: The Truth About Pricing by Melina Palmer
OVERVIEW
Every growth-stage CEO I work with has the same pricing story. A proposal goes out. The prospect pushes back. The CEO assumes the number was too high and debates whether to discount. Then the pattern repeats. The real issue is rarely the number. But as long as leaders keep staring at the number, they never fix the thing that actually drives the decision.
Melina Palmer is the founder of The Brainy Business, a behavioral economics consulting and training firm, and an instructor of applied behavioral economics through the Texas A&M Human Behavior Lab. Her first two books tackled what customers want and what employees need. This third book brings that same behavioral science lens directly to pricing.
Palmer's argument is simple and a little uncomfortable: pricing decisions happen in the subconscious mind, long before a customer sees any number. The number is nearly irrelevant. What matters is everything that has already shaped how the buyer perceives value, trust, and identity by the time the price appears.
CONCEPTS
The subconscious brain runs the show. - Most buying decisions are made subconsciously, using fast pattern-matching and emotion rather than deliberate cost-benefit analysis. Buyers are not reading your proposal like a spreadsheet. They are running it against a set of gut-level impressions already formed. By the time someone is looking at your price, their brain has often already decided. The rational evaluation is mostly post-hoc justification.
Framing shapes perceived value more than the number does. - How you position an offering, what you compare it to, what you say first, and how you describe the problem it solves all affect what the price feels like to a buyer. Two identical offers priced identically can land completely differently depending on the context around them. Framing is not spin. It is the mechanism by which the brain assigns meaning, and ignoring it leaves real revenue on the table.
Anchoring gives buyers a reference point they didn't have before. - When someone has no existing reference for what something should cost, they will grab whatever number is presented first and use it as their anchor. A higher-priced option introduced early, sometimes called a "wingman" offer, makes the primary offer feel more reasonable by comparison. Without an anchor, buyers default to either the cheapest comparison they can find or to sticker shock. You do not have to sell the high-end option. You just need it visible.
Quality positioning and value positioning are not interchangeable. - Palmer draws a sharp line between businesses that compete on quality and businesses that compete on value. Quality buyers are not primarily price-sensitive. Value buyers are, and they need to be spoken to differently. Getting this wrong means you end up attracting the wrong customer, having the wrong conversation, and constantly defending a price that was never meant to be defended.
Confidence in delivery changes how the price lands. - The way a price is presented matters as much as the price itself. Hesitation, apology, or heavy qualification before announcing a number signals to the buyer that even the seller is unsure it's worth it. Stating a price with the same flat confidence as stating a fact removes friction and reduces pushback. This is not about being aggressive. It is about not undermining your own positioning before the buyer even responds.
APPLICATION
Audit what comes before the number. - Before your next pricing review, map everything that happens before a prospect sees your price. What does your website say? How do your salespeople frame the conversation? What problems do you lead with, and what transformation do you describe? Most companies discover that the setup for the price is weak and inconsistent. The number is not what needs fixing. The story that precedes it is. I have seen companies raise prices without changing a single number, just by tightening the framing that leads up to it.
Build an anchor into every offer structure. - If your current approach is to present one option and hope the buyer agrees to it, you are leaving the anchor in the buyer's hands. They will find their own reference point and it will almost certainly be the cheapest alternative they can think of. Build a higher-tier option into your proposal or service menu. It does not have to be something you expect to sell. Its job is to make your primary offer look like the obvious, sensible choice. Structure the anchor so the comparison is clear and the middle path feels like the smart decision.
Get clear on whether you compete on quality or value. - This distinction matters more than most teams realize. Sit down with your leadership team and answer this honestly: do your best customers buy from you because you are the safest, most capable, most trusted provider, or because you offer the most for the money? The answer shapes every pricing and positioning decision downstream. If you try to appeal to both audiences with the same language and structure, you end up convincing neither. Pick your lane and build your pricing story around it.
Train your team on confident price delivery. - If you have people presenting proposals or closing deals, watch how they talk about price. Listen for hedging language, pre-emptive apology, or the habit of jumping to discounts before the buyer has even responded. Most salespeople never get coaching on this specific moment, and it costs companies more than a bad pricing structure ever would. Role-play the price conversation until flat, confident delivery becomes the default. This is a trainable skill and it moves the needle fast.
Stop treating discounting as a closing tool. - Discounting signals that the original price was arbitrary, which means the buyer learns to always push for a lower number. If deals regularly close only after a discount, the problem is upstream in how value is communicated, not in the price itself. I push my clients to trace every discounted deal backward and find the moment where the value story broke down. Fix that moment and the pressure to discount starts to ease. Discounting as a habit is expensive, and it trains your market to expect it.
TAKEAWAY
Most pricing problems are not pricing problems at all. They are framing problems, positioning problems, and confidence problems. Obsessing over the number is how companies stay stuck, because the number is the last thing the buyer's brain actually processes. Palmer's book is a practical guide to working with how the brain actually makes decisions instead of pretending buyers are rational actors doing spreadsheet math. For growth-stage companies especially, where pricing is often set by instinct and defended by habit, the opportunity to reset the value story is significant. If your team is regularly losing on price or discounting to close, the answer is almost never a lower number. It is a better setup.
Newsletter
If you find these summaries useful, sign up for my weekly newsletter. I publish every week to over 5,000 CEOs and leadership team members covering strategy, leadership, scaling, and the ideas that help growth-stage companies perform at their best.
