Your Annual Budget Is Lying to You
The annual budget is one of the most damaging rituals in business, and the companies that have abandoned it are outperforming the ones that haven't.
Book Review: Beyond Budgeting by Jeremy Hope and Robin Fraser
OVERVIEW
Every fall, leadership teams go through the same ritual. Weeks of spreadsheets, endless negotiation, a final number that everyone signs off on and nobody actually believes. By March, the market has shifted, a key hire fell through, or a competitor made a move nobody saw coming. Suddenly you're defending a plan built on assumptions that no longer exist.
Jeremy Hope and Robin Fraser spent years studying companies that ditched the annual budget entirely, including Swedish bank Svenska Handelsbanken, IKEA, and British truck manufacturer Leyland Trucks. What they found was that these companies didn't just save time on planning. They outperformed their industries, made faster decisions, and built cultures where people felt accountable for real outcomes instead of hitting an arbitrary number.
Their argument is blunt: the annual budget isn't just inefficient, it's actively harmful. It turns managers into number-gamers instead of value-creators. And for growth-stage companies especially, it locks you into decisions made with last year's thinking.
CONCEPTS
The fixed performance contract problem. - When you tie compensation and performance reviews to hitting a number, your team will hit that number and not much more. Smart people quickly figure out that exceeding the budget just raises next year's target, so sandbagging becomes rational. What looks like a planning problem is actually a culture problem, and the budget created it.
Rolling forecasts replace the annual plan. - By the time you're three months into the year, the assumptions baked into your budget have started to expire. Rolling forecasts, updating your view of the next four to six quarters on a regular basis, keep you looking forward the same distance all the time instead of counting down to December. You stop ignoring new information and start acting on it.
Decentralized decision-making. - The annual budget is a control mechanism dressed up as a planning tool. When managers need approval for anything that wasn't in the original plan, the message is clear: don't act, ask. Hope and Fraser argue for pushing authority closer to the customer with clear guardrails, so the people with the most current information can actually use it.
Relative performance over fixed targets. - Your budget target was negotiated against internal assumptions. What actually matters is whether you're improving faster than your market and your competitors. A team that misses budget in a down market may be doing exceptional work. A team that hits budget in a boom may be leaving a lot on the table. Relative performance is a more honest measure.
APPLICATION
Audit your last budget conversation for sandbagging. - If your managers were negotiating targets down rather than pushing them up, your budget process is punishing honesty. That's a cultural signal worth taking seriously before you change anything else. Ask yourself: did anyone on your team argue for a higher target than you expected? If the answer is no, the incentive structure is working against you. People optimize for what they get rewarded for, and right now they're getting rewarded for playing it safe.
Separate planning from forecasting. - Your strategic plan sets direction. Your forecast reflects current reality. Treating them as the same document is where most companies get into trouble. Try maintaining a simple rolling forecast, updated monthly or quarterly, that sits alongside your annual plan. When market conditions shift or a major assumption changes, you update the forecast without blowing up the strategic plan. You always know where you're actually headed, not just where you hoped to be in October.
Connect budget discussions to strategy, not history. - Most budget conversations start with last year's numbers and work forward from there. That's backwards. Start with your strategic priorities instead. What do you need to accomplish in the next one to three years, and what does that require? Work backward to what you need to invest now. This shift alone changes the quality of the conversation from defending last year's spend to building the business you're trying to create.
Use Commander's Intent for financial guardrails. - Instead of requiring approval for every unplanned expense, define the outcome you want, set clear parameters around spend, and let your team make decisions within those boundaries. Be explicit: here's the goal, here's what you have to work with, here's what requires escalation. You stop being the bottleneck on routine decisions, your managers start thinking like owners, and the business moves faster without losing financial discipline.
Reframe performance conversations around improvement rate. - When you review results, ask not just whether you hit the number, but whether you got better. Are you improving faster than last quarter? Faster than your competitors? A team that misses budget in a brutal market but closes the gap every month is doing something right. A team that hits budget in a booming market but loses ground to competitors is in trouble. Improvement rate is a more honest signal than budget compliance, and it keeps your team focused on the right question.
TAKEAWAY
If your team is negotiating targets down instead of pushing them up, your budget process is working against you. No amount of better spreadsheets will fix that. The real problem isn't the numbers, it's the incentive structure underneath them. When hitting the budget becomes the goal, people stop trying to build the business and start trying to protect their number. The fix isn't a new template or a tighter review process. It's rethinking what you're actually asking your team to optimize for. That starts with the conversation you have this fall before the next budget cycle begins.
Related Summaries
Book Summary Placeholder One
Book Summary Placeholder Two
Book Summary Placeholder Three
Newsletter
If you find these summaries useful, sign up for my weekly newsletter. I publish every week to over 5,000 CEOs and leadership team members covering strategy, leadership, scaling, and the ideas that help growth-stage companies perform at their best.
