Eckfeldt + Associates

Inc.com Column

How to Play Devil’s Advocate in a Productive Way

Agreement can conceal risks and leave teams with untested assumptions. Ask someone to examine the reasoning and evidence, then offer options that serve the team's shared aim. Rotate the role and move on when debate stops improving the decision.

By Bruce Eckfeldt

Published on Inc.com, May 22, 2020

A man in a suit standing in front of a red light
Photo by Andrej Lisakov on Unsplash

Overview

The column argues that teams need deliberate disagreement to catch blind spots and improve decisions. A person who tests the prevailing view can help a group examine evidence, consider risks, and discover options that agreement alone may miss. But the role only works when challenge serves better thinking rather than conflict for its own sake.

Productive dissent stays focused on ideas, not the people who raise them. It relies on clear reasoning and relevant evidence, and it adds possible paths instead of only tearing down a proposal. The person challenging the group should act for the team’s shared goal, not use debate to advance a private grievance. When a counterargument has been explored and adds no more value, the team should move forward.

The column also warns against assigning this role to one permanent skeptic. Rotating it helps everyone practice critical thinking and keeps disagreement from becoming a predictable personality dynamic. For founder-led teams, that means making room for respectful challenge while protecting momentum. The aim is not to argue more, but to make stronger choices together.

Key Points

  • Use dissent to reveal blind spots and test assumptions before making a decision.
  • Challenge the reasoning and evidence behind ideas, not the people who present them.
  • Offer alternatives so debate can lead the team toward better options.
  • Keep disagreement focused on shared goals rather than personal agendas.
  • Rotate the role and move on when further debate no longer improves the decision.

Why I Wrote It

Some leadership teams agree too quickly, while others turn challenge into personal friction or prolonged debate. I see productive dissent as a way to test assumptions and widen options, not to win an argument. This piece helps leaders make room for respectful challenge, then move forward when it has done its job.

The Full Article

The complete column, with the full reasoning and examples, is on Inc.com.

Read the Full Article on Inc.com

Share This Post

Pass It On.

Know a founder or leadership team working through this? Send it their way.

Bruce Eckfeldt is a business coach and strategic advisor to founder-CEOs of growth-stage companies and a former Inc. 500 CEO. He writes a column for Inc.com, hosts the From Angel to Exit podcast, and is the author of Springboard, a founder's guide to selling your company. Connect with him on LinkedIn.

The Related Program

Put It to Work.

LEADERSHIP360 helps leadership teams build the trust and habits needed to challenge ideas productively and make stronger decisions.

Leadership Team Program LEADERSHIP360

Does every decision still run through you?

Your company has outgrown what one person can hold. LEADERSHIP360 builds the leadership team, the accountability, and the operating rhythm that let the business run without you in the room.

Duration
In 90 days and five stages, LEADERSHIP360 evaluates the current team, clarifies roles and responsibilities, and builds a culture of accountability across the organization.
Built for
Founder-CEOs and their leadership teams at growth-stage companies.
Method
Behavioral and cognitive assessments, team surveys, and one-to-one interviews with every leader.
Outcome
The right people in the right seats, clear accountability for every key role, and a team that runs the business without routing every decision through you.
Take the Next Step

Two Ways to Take It From Here.

If you already know the team is the constraint, a strategy call gets straight to it. If you would rather see where you stand first, an assessment is the lighter way in.

Talk It Through

A focused conversation about your leadership team, where it is holding the business back, and what to do first. No proposal at the end unless you ask for one.

  • Where the team is the constraint today
  • Which seats and roles to address first
  • Whether LEADERSHIP360 fits, and when

No proposal at the end unless you ask for one.

Score It Yourself

Ten minutes, 24 statements, and an instant read on where you stand. No login and no email gate.

  • 24 statements each, scored instantly
  • No login and no email gate
  • Optional full report with next steps

Most founders take both and compare the results.

Related Reading

Keep Going.

More on this topic from the Inc.com column, Field Notes, and The Playbook.

From the Inc.com Column
From Field Notes
Better, Faster: Subscribe

Get the Next One.

Every new post and playbook lands in Better, Faster, my weekly newsletter for founder-CEOs, along with questions for your team and a book worth reading.

Join Better, Faster

Free every week. One question, a short video, and a conversation worth joining.

  • One question worth taking to your leadership team.
  • A short video with my take.
  • A conversation with founder-CEOs facing the same problems.
  • LinkedIn Live replays, new podcast episodes, and a book review.

One email every Thursday, free. Unsubscribe any time.