Eckfeldt + Associates

Field Notes Strategy

Why Most Business KPIs Hide Where Your Profit Actually Comes From

Your company can report strong margins while hiding which customers, services, or routes actually create profit. Operational Profit cuts results by the units your team manages, helping people see how everyday choices affect contribution and make better decisions about customers, pricing, and service.

By Bruce Eckfeldt

November 10, 202610 min readStrategy, Planning

A red apple cut into three upright slices, standing apart on a pale mint background
Photo, Unsplash

The Problem

Ask a leadership team how profitable the company was last year and someone will have the number ready. Gross margin, EBITDA, net profit. Usually to the decimal.

Then ask which customers produced that profit. Which services. Which routes, product lines, or locations. The room goes quiet.

That silence is the gap. Most business KPIs measure profit as a financial result. They compare one line of the income statement to another and tell you how the company did. What they don’t show is where the profit comes from. I call that missing view Operational Profit. It’s profit measured by the units your team actually manages, like a customer, a delivery, a service line, or a project. It isn’t the accounting figure called operating profit. It’s the same profit, cut so the people making daily decisions can see what those decisions do to it.

I learned this running my own agency. For years we watched revenue and margin at the company level. It wasn’t until we looked at how much profit each client actually generated that we started asking better questions. What mix of people were we putting on each client? What ratios did we need to hit to make an engagement profitable? Some of our biggest clients by revenue turned out to contribute far less than we’d assumed. The financials weren’t wrong. They just couldn’t tell us where to look.

Most Business KPIs Tell You How Much, Not Where

Look at the business KPIs on most leadership dashboards and you’ll find the same handful of numbers. Revenue and revenue growth. Gross margin percent. EBITDA. Maybe cash and days sales outstanding. Every one of them is a financial ratio. They compare one line of the income statement to another, or this year to last.

These are good numbers. You need them. They tell you whether the business is healthy, whether costs are creeping, and whether you can fund the next stage of growth. Keep reporting them. Keep reviewing them every month.

The problem is what happens when they’re the only view of profit the team has.

Your sales team doesn’t make decisions about EBITDA. They decide which prospects to chase, which deals to discount, and which accounts get their time. Operations decides how to staff a job, which orders to rush, and which customers get extra service. Marketing decides where to spend. Each of those choices changes profit. None of them shows up on a dashboard of financial ratios until weeks later, blended in with everything else.

So each function fills the gap with the number it can see. Sales chases revenue and bookings. Operations chases utilization and on-time delivery. Marketing chases leads. All of those numbers can go up while profit goes sideways, because none of them knows which revenue is worth having.

That’s the real cost. Not bad reporting. A team making hundreds of small profit decisions every week with no way to see their effect.

Your Biggest Customers May Not Be Your Most Profitable

Company-level reporting hides this for a simple reason. Most cost systems spread overhead across the business evenly, or in proportion to revenue. That assumes every dollar of revenue costs about the same to earn. It almost never does.

Some customers order in small batches. Some ask for custom work, rush jobs, or extra support. Some pay late. Some need three meetings to approve anything. Each of those habits costs money to serve, and none of it shows up when profit is reported as one margin for the whole company. Revenue gets reported by customer. Cost to serve usually doesn’t.

The classic example is Kanthal, a Swedish maker of heating wire. Robert Kaplan and Robin Cooper wrote about what happened when the company started measuring profit customer by customer. The most profitable 20 percent of customers generated 225 percent of total profits. The middle 70 percent roughly broke even. The least profitable 10 percent lost 125 percent of total profits, giving back more than half of what the best customers earned. Some of the company’s largest customers turned out to be among the least profitable.

Read those numbers again. The company was profitable overall. Its financial statements looked fine. Yet a small group of customers was quietly erasing more profit than the company actually reported. Nobody could see it, because nobody was looking at profit that way.

Kaplan’s later research found the same shape across many companies. A small group of customers often generates well over 100 percent of profits, while the bottom group gives a large share of it back. If you’ve never cut your profit by customer, assume your business looks something like this until you know otherwise.

Your P&L tells you how much you made. It can’t tell you who you made it from.

What Changes When the Team Can See It

Seeing profit by unit is useful for the CEO. It becomes powerful when the whole team can see it, because that’s when daily decisions start to change.

New System Laundry is a good example. It’s a fourth-generation, family-owned commercial laundry in the Pacific Northwest that rents and cleans linens and uniforms for restaurants, hospitality, and healthcare. Verne Harnish tells its story in Scaling Up. The leadership team settled on one measure of profit to run the business on: gross profit per delivery.

The point wasn’t to give finance a new report. It was to give every employee a number they could connect to their own job. A driver, a sales rep, a plant supervisor, and a customer service rep all do different work. Each of them can ask the same question. How does what I do today raise or lower our gross profit per delivery?

Think about what that number rewards. A truck already running a route costs about the same whether it makes ten stops or twelve. The driver, the fuel, and the time on the road are mostly spent either way. So a new customer on an existing route adds revenue with very little added cost, and gross profit per delivery goes up. A new customer across town, off every route, might bring the same revenue and far more cost. On a revenue dashboard the two look identical. Measured by gross profit per delivery, one is clearly better business.

A number like that changes where sales looks for customers, where marketing spends, and how operations plans routes. Nobody needs a memo about route density. The number makes the better choice visible.

You can see the same shift in restaurants that practice menu engineering. Many restaurants manage their menu by food cost percentage, which is a financial ratio. By that measure, a pasta dish with a 20 percent food cost looks better than a steak at 35 percent. Now put prices on them. Say the pasta sells for $18. It contributes $14.40 toward overhead and profit. Say the steak sells for $42. It contributes $27.30. The steak is the more profitable plate, even though its ratio looks worse. Restaurants that switch to contribution per dish start pricing, placing, and promoting their menu differently. Same kitchen, same menu, different decisions.

Diagnostic: Can Your Team See Operational Profit?

Run these five questions with your leadership team. They’ll show you quickly whether your business performance metrics reveal where profit comes from, or only how much you made.

  1. Can you rank your top 20 customers by profit, not just revenue? If you can only rank them by revenue, you don’t know which ones are carrying the business. Rough numbers count. A best guess you can defend beats a precise list sorted the wrong way.
  2. Does your sales team know which deals make money? Look at how deals get approved and how reps get paid. If both run on revenue or bookings, your sales team is steering by volume. They’ll bring in work that looks good on the top line and costs you on the bottom.
  3. Can anyone below the CEO see profit by service line, product, or location? A profitability analysis that lives in the CFO’s spreadsheet doesn’t change daily decisions. The people choosing where to spend their time need to see it too.
  4. Do your leaders agree on which customers or offerings are most profitable? Ask each leader separately, then compare. Disagreement here means everyone is working from a different picture of the business.
  5. When a big customer asks for a discount or extra service, how do you decide? If the answer is gut feel or the size of the account, you’re deciding without the information that matters most.

If you answered no, or not sure, to two or more of these, your team is working without an operational view of profit.

Where to Start: Pick the Unit, Then Make It Visible

You don’t need a new accounting system to start. You need a few deliberate choices.

  1. Pick one unit that matches how you make money. Customer, delivery, project, service line, location, or product. Choose the one that best reflects what drives profit in your business, and one your team can actually influence. You can add others later. Start with one.
  2. Use contribution margin, not net profit. Take the revenue for each unit and subtract the costs that clearly belong to it: direct labor, materials, delivery, and the time it takes to serve. Leave the overhead allocation debates for later. A rough contribution by unit is far more useful than a perfect number for the whole company.
  3. Show it to the people who make the calls. Put the numbers in front of sales, operations, and marketing, not just finance. Walk through the surprises together. The first look usually starts a few uncomfortable conversations. That’s the point.
  4. Make it a standing number. Add it to the business KPIs on your dashboard and review it in your monthly meeting rhythm. A one-time customer profitability study gets a good discussion and then fades. A number the team reviews every month changes behavior.

Picking the unit is the hardest step, and the one that matters most. The unit you choose decides what your team optimizes. Pick one that’s easy to measure but disconnected from how you make money, and you’ll get busywork. Pick the right one and it becomes the single number that ties daily operations to financial results.

I use a one-page Profit Per X worksheet with leadership teams to test candidate units and choose one, along with worked examples from well-known companies. Download the Profit Per X worksheet (free with registration). Bring your team, list more candidates than feels necessary, and argue about which one would change your decisions the most.

Questions for You and Your Team

Bring these to your next leadership meeting. Have each person answer on their own first, then compare.

  • Which customer or service line do we assume is most profitable, and have we checked? Most teams carry a story about where they make money. It’s usually based on revenue, size, or which work people enjoy. The check is often surprising.
  • What decision would we make differently this quarter if we could see profit by customer? Pricing, staffing, which deals to pursue, which accounts to grow. Naming the decision shows what the missing view is costing you.
  • Who on our team makes daily choices that affect profit but never sees it? The list is usually longer than expected. Each name on it is someone steering without a gauge.

The goal isn’t to have perfect answers. It’s to surface whether a missing view of Operational Profit might be affecting your business.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is operational profit?

Operational profit is profit measured by the units your team manages day to day, such as a customer, a delivery, a project, a service line, or a location. It uses the same financial data as your income statement, cut a different way. The goal is to show the people making operational decisions how those decisions affect profit.

How is operational profit different from operating profit?

Operating profit is an accounting figure. It’s revenue minus operating expenses for the whole company, and it appears on your income statement. Operational profit isn’t a line on the statement. It breaks profit down by the units your business runs on, so you can see which customers, services, or routes create it and which ones drain it.

Do I need activity-based costing to measure profit by customer?

No. Activity-based costing gives the most precise answer, but you can start with contribution margin. Subtract the costs that clearly belong to each customer or unit, such as direct labor, materials, and delivery, from the revenue it brings in. A rough view is enough to show where the big differences are.

Which unit should we measure first?

Start with the unit that best reflects how your business makes money and that your team can influence. For a services firm that’s often the client or the project. For a route-based business it’s the stop or the delivery. For a business with several offerings it’s the service line or product. Pick one, measure it, and review it monthly before adding more.

Which business KPIs should we keep?

Keep your financial KPIs: revenue, gross margin, EBITDA, and cash. They tell you whether the business is healthy. Add one operational view of profit alongside them, so the team can see how its daily choices drive those results.

Share This Post

Pass It On.

Know a founder or leadership team working through this? Send it their way.

Bruce Eckfeldt is a business coach and strategic advisor to founder-CEOs of growth-stage companies and a former Inc. 500 CEO. He writes a column for Inc.com, hosts the From Angel to Exit podcast, and is the author of Springboard, a founder's guide to selling your company. Connect with him on LinkedIn.

Better, Faster: Subscribe

Get the Next One.

Every new post and playbook lands in Better, Faster, my weekly newsletter for founder-CEOs, along with questions for your team and a book worth reading.

Join Better, Faster

Free every week. One question, a short video, and a conversation worth joining.

  • One question worth taking to your leadership team.
  • A short video with my take.
  • A conversation with founder-CEOs facing the same problems.
  • LinkedIn Live replays, new podcast episodes, and a book review.

One email every Thursday, free. Unsubscribe any time.